Philip J. Fulton Law Office
Call For Your Free Consultation Today
Columbus, OH Office 614-929-3126

Ohio Supreme Court upholds workers' rights in employer retaliation case

In Ohio, it is illegal for an employer to fire, demote or retaliate against an employee simply because he or she files or pursues a workers' compensation claim. While this anti-retaliation law is one of the bedrocks of Ohio's workers compensation system, its application was recently questioned in case before the Ohio Supreme Court.

In the opinion titled Onderko v. Sierra Lobo, Inc., the court was asked to decide whether injured employees who have been retaliated against by their bosses must first prove their injuries occurred at work before they can file a claim under Ohio's workers' compensation anti-retaliation statute. The court determined they do not - thereby protecting the rights of Ohio workers and preventing them from having to choose between their jobs and workers' comp benefits they deserve.

Proving employer retaliation

While, in this case, there was some dispute about whether or not the employee's injuries were actually work-related, the court said, in effect, it didn't matter. In fact, according to the plain language of the retaliation statue, the court determined that a prima facie case for retaliation requires an employee to prove only the following:

  • The employer discharged, demoted, reassigned or took any other form of punitive action against the employee
  • This punitive action was taken in retaliation for the employee's filing of a workers' compensation claim or pursuing/testifying in any workers' comp proceeding

As you can see, there is no requirement that the injured employee actually prove that his or her injuries were work-related. Indeed, in its decision, the court cited the opinion of the appeals court, which said,

"Requiring an employee to successfully prove that the injury occurred at work for purposes of a retaliatory-discharge claim would have a chilling effect on the exercise of his or her rights because the employee would be forced to choose between a continuation of employment and the submission of a workers' compensation claim. This choice must be made by the employee knowing that if he or she fails to prove that the cause of the injury was work related, not only will his or her claim be denied, but the employer would then be free to terminate the employment simply because the claim was filed."

The Ohio Supreme Court also went on to say, "We resist interpreting the anti-retaliation statute in such a way that would vest employers with the discretion to label any unsuccessful claim as deceptive and then terminate the employee."

In the end, this decision is a victory for all employees who suffer from retaliation by their employers simply because they seek the workers comp benefits they are entitled to.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Take The First Step And Contact Us Today

Free Consultations

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Write Us A Review

At Philip J. Fulton Law Office, we love feedback from our clients. Please take a moment, and tell us how we’re doing!

Philip J. Fulton Law OfficeRepresenting Victims Of Workplace Injuries And Disability

89 East Nationwide Boulevard
Suite 300
Columbus, OH 43215

Toll Free: 866-552-6353
Phone: 614-929-3126
Phone: 614-224-3838
Fax: 614-224-3933
Columbus Personal Injury Office Map

Free Consultations:
Back To Top